2012，COMODO VS AVIRA，啟發式偵測率測試 (by FaraVirusi.com Labs)

a256886572008

原帖：
http://www.faravirusi.com/2011/11/06/avira-antivirus-free-2012-vs-comodo-antivirus-2012-test-al-detectiei-by-faravirusi-com/

正文：
Many visitors asked me which is Comodo’s Antivirus 2012 (5.8) detection rate and how good it is to prevent an infection.

So I decided to do a complete and complex test in order to evaluate the detection of this product using a total of 21.390 viruses between the 18th of October to 24th of October, 2011.

I have chosen Avira Antivirus Free 2012 for comparison, testing it on the same malware set.
Why this product? Because it has the best detection (according to AV-Comparatives) among single-engine products and in addition these are both free software.

How did I conducted this test?
I set both products to use the best settings for maximum detection (scan all files, heuristics on the maximum

level) and during a week time, I scanned a set of malwares.
Scanning evaluated immediate detection of both products, so I tested them no later than 48H after I had found all

the malwares I used for a test in a specific day.

Which was the final result?
Comodo – 83.94% detection
Avira – 82.98% detection

For additional details, I will post below the specific detection rate day by day:

October 18:
Initial files – 3073
Avira – 720 remaining (76.5% detection)
Comodo – 782 remaining (74.55% detection)

October 19:
Initial files – 3078
Avira – the remaining 733 (76.18% detection)
Comodo – 487 remaining (84.17% detection)

October 20:
Initial files – 3021
Avira – 389 remaining (87.12% detection)
Comodo – 281 remaining (90.69% detection)

October 21:
Initial files – 3045
Avira – 494 remaining (83.77% detection)
Comodo – remaining 567 (81.37% detection)

October 22:
Initial files – 3030
Avira – 562 remaining (81.45% detection)
Comodo – 583 remaining (80.75% detection)

October 23:
Initial files – 3118
Avira – 402 remaining (87.10%)
Comodo – 311 remaining (90.02%)

October 24:
Initial files – 3025
Avira – 340 remaining (88.76%)
Comodo – 429 remaining (85.81%)

Finally, we evaluated the heuristic detection for Comodo Antivirus 5.8 (2012).

The product used the signatures it had on the 27th of October 2011. We used new malware appeared between the 2nd of November to 4th of November 2011, a total of 9150 infected files.

Proactive detection was 4274 (46.71%), a good result, but there is room for improvement, considering that a very good heuristic detection starts from 50%.

阿童木看星星

不会吧。。。。comodo超过了红伞

ppy0606

  不错·

  CIS的路过

zyx9

从来没小看毛豆的启发 毛豆整体实力值得肯定 只是名气不如3a 假以时日必定超越3a

jefffire

初步看了一下，没发现有可靠的测试启发的方法。LZ标题党。

solstice1988

启发两者差不多，但是再加上特征码..............

z13667152750

jefffire 发表于 2011-11-6 18:30
初步看了一下，没发现有可靠的测试启发的方法。LZ标题党。

有锁库测试

jefffire

z13667152750 发表于 2011-11-6 18:32
有锁库测试

看见了，最后有。
comodo的引擎重写后确实比以前强了。以前的引擎是08年的时候，金山的姚辉跳槽到comodo写的，什么玩意儿。

a256886572008

solstice1988 发表于 2011-11-6 18:31
启发两者差不多，但是再加上特征码..............

還沒加上  雲端呢

jefffire

a256886572008 发表于 2011-11-6 18:37
還沒加上  雲端呢

comodo是小众产品。如果comodo能到avira的占有率还能保持这个水平才是牛。