这是硬盘坏道吗？该怎么办？

wjcharles

十一期间某次死机后重启就蓝屏，用vista安装光盘修复，结果系统日志中出现如下错误上百个

日志名称:          System
来源:            disk
日期:            2010/10/8 11:02:10
事件 ID:         11
任务类别:          无
级别:            错误
关键字:           经典
用户:            暂缺
计算机:           LH-2UYY8QJXV2NM
说明:
驱动程序在 \Device\Harddisk0\DR0 上检测到控制器错误。
事件 Xml:
<Event xmlns="http://schemas.microsoft.com/win/2004/08/events/event">
<System>
   <;Provider Name="disk" />
   <EventID Qualifiers="49156">11</EventID>
   <Level>2</Level>
   <Task>0</Task>
   <Keywords>0x80000000000000</Keywords>
   <TimeCreated SystemTime="2010-10-08T03:02:10.927Z" />
   <EventRecordID>163861</EventRecordID>
   <Channel>System</Channel>
   <Computer>LH-2UYY8QJXV2NM</Computer>
   <Security />
</System>
<EventData>
   <Data>\Device\Harddisk0\DR0</Data>
   <Binary>0400680001000000000000000B0004C00301000000000000000000000000000000000000000000005DBF1F0000000000FFFFFFFF07000000400000050000000006200A128001204000C000003C00000000B09F856013E39900000000384AF79900000000B0B264032A000364B2B000006000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000</Binary>
</EventData>
</Event>

怀疑硬盘有问题，chkdsk几次没有用，hdd regenerator扫描修复失败，victoria扫描得到以下结果

2:12:28 : 获取详细信息... OK
2:12:40 : 重置... OK
2:12:40 : 块 60978 错误: ABRT
2:12:40 : 开始读取, LBA=0..625142447, 向前扫描, 超时 10000ms
2:13:06 : 块 61184 错误: ABRT
2:13:06 : 警告! 块起始与 61440 = 25475 ms
2:13:10 : 警告! 块起始与 601088 = 234 ms
2:13:10 : 警告! 块起始与 601088 = 250 ms
2:13:19 : 警告! 块起始与 1668096 = 202 ms
2:13:45 : 警告! 块起始与 5089536 = 234 ms
2:13:45 : 警告! 块起始与 5089792 = 655 ms
2:13:45 : 警告! 块起始与 5089792 = 421 ms
2:14:20 : 块 6323456 错误: ABRT
2:14:21 : 警告! 块起始与 6323712 = 24695 ms
2:16:39 : 警告! 块起始与 24620800 = 2168 ms
2:16:39 : 警告! 块起始与 24621056 = 2028 ms
2:19:28 : 块 39481344 错误: ABRT
2:19:59 : 块 39481600 错误: ABRT
2:19:59 : 警告! 块起始与 39481856 = 30358 ms
2:20:12 : 警告! 块起始与 40620800 = 203 ms
2:20:12 : 警告! 块起始与 40621056 = 16 ms
2:21:19 : 块 46903808 错误: ABRT
2:21:19 : 警告! 块起始与 46904064 = 25226 ms
2:21:46 : 警告! 块起始与 50844160 = 858 ms
2:21:46 : 警告! 块起始与 50844416 = 889 ms
2:21:48 : 警告! 块起始与 51070464 = 203 ms
2:21:48 : 警告! 块起始与 51070720 = 219 ms
2:22:03 : 警告! 块起始与 53147904 = 203 ms
2:22:03 : 警告! 块起始与 53147904 = 203 ms
2:22:16 : 警告! 块起始与 54802688 = 297 ms
2:22:16 : 警告! 块起始与 54802944 = 265 ms
2:22:16 : 警告! 块起始与 54806016 = 219 ms
2:23:41 : 警告! 块起始与 67732224 = 312 ms
2:23:48 : 警告! 块起始与 67732480 = 7378 ms
2:23:48 : 警告! 块起始与 67732736 = 7113 ms
2:23:49 : 警告! 块起始与 67762432 = 405 ms
2:23:50 : 警告! 块起始与 67762688 = 1388 ms
2:23:50 : 警告! 块起始与 67762944 = 999 ms
2:24:01 : 警告! 块起始与 69026048 = 624 ms
2:24:01 : 警告! 块起始与 69026304 = 624 ms
2:24:02 : 警告! 块起始与 69064960 = 406 ms
2:24:02 : 警告! 块起始与 69065216 = 406 ms
2:26:54 : 警告! 块起始与 96274176 = 811 ms
2:26:54 : 警告! 块起始与 96274432 = 842 ms
2:29:22 : 警告! 块起始与 119736832 = 312 ms
2:29:22 : 警告! 块起始与 119736832 = 312 ms
2:32:26 : 警告! 块起始与 147194368 = 312 ms
2:32:26 : 警告! 块起始与 147194624 = 328 ms
2:33:25 : 警告! 块起始与 151753216 = 1529 ms
2:33:26 : 警告! 块起始与 151753472 = 2216 ms
2:33:27 : 警告! 块起始与 151753728 = 1747 ms
2:33:27 : 警告! 块起始与 151753984 = 1076 ms
3:01:27 : 警告! 块起始与 405690368 = 359 ms
3:01:27 : 警告! 块起始与 405690368 = 202 ms
3:01:28 : 警告! 块起始与 405926656 = 203 ms
3:01:29 : 警告! 块起始与 405926912 = 375 ms
3:01:29 : 警告! 块起始与 405926912 = 219 ms
3:12:55 : 警告! 块起始与 498976000 = 202 ms
3:21:56 : 警告! 块起始与 562516736 = 203 ms
3:21:56 : 警告! 块起始与 562516992 = 219 ms
3:29:22 : 警告! 块起始与 609726208 = 280 ms
3:29:22 : 警告! 块起始与 609726208 = 280 ms
3:31:15 : 警告! 块起始与 620985088 = 1700 ms
3:31:15 : 警告! 块起始与 620985344 = 1731 ms
3:32:00 : ***** 扫描结果: 警告 - 55, 错误 - 5 *****
3:32:00 : ***** 扫描结果: 警告 - 55, 错误 - 5 *****

附smart信息


ST9320423AS   
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
ID      名称             数值  属性最坏值  阈值       原始值    健康值
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
  1 数据读取错误率                103     80      6     46798093   晻晻?
  3 到指定转数                     98     97     85            0   晻晻  
  4 到指定转数时间次数            100    100     20          370   晻晻?
  5 重新分配扇区数量              100    100     36            2   晻晻?
  7 寻道错误率                     84     60     30   9065101206   晻晻  
  9 加电累计时间                   91     91      0         8429   晻晻  
10 到指定转数次数                100    100     97            0   晻晻?
12 启动/停止总计                 100     37     20          341   晻晻?
184 末尾结束错误率                100    100     99            0   晻晻?
187 报告无法纠正扇区                1      1      0         3478   ?   
188 指令超时                      100     94      0          162   晻晻?
189 定位写入准确率                100    100      0            0   晻晻?
190 气流温度                       63     47     45    37癈/98癋   晻晻  
191 震动传感出错率                100    100      0            7   晻晻?
192 磁头断电回位次数              100    100      0           12   晻晻?
193 磁头载入/载出次数              84     84      0        33065   晻晻  
194 盘体温度                       37     53      0    37癈/98癋   晻晻  
194 最低温度                       90     53      0    10癈/50癋   -     
195 硬件错误纠正次数               44     28      0     46798093   晻   
197 当前待映射扇区数量            100    100      0           27   晻晻?
198 离线无法纠正扇区数量          100    100      0           27   晻晻?
199 Ultra DMA CRC 错误率          200    200      0            0   晻晻?
240 磁头定位时间                  100    253      0  128307853009067   晻晻?
241 未知属性                      100    253      0    643382978   晻晻?
242 未知属性                      100    253      0   2530475973   晻晻?
254 震动传感出错率                100    100      0            0   晻晻?


现在应该怎么办？？能不能屏蔽或重映射？

北方星空

hddscan扫描一下看看，基本上可能是坏道

mylky

   硬盘不会那么容易出坏道的，如果出了硬盘也就OVER了！还是找找其它原因吧！

njwin

5 重新分配扇区数量              100    100     36            2   晻晻?
有问题

wjcharles

北方星空 发表于 2010.10.8 12:20
hddscan扫描一下看看，基本上可能是坏道

结果还是不妙。。。



HDDScan Drive Test Report
Model: ST9320423AS
Firmware: 0002SDM1
Serial:
LBA: 625142448

Report By: HDDScan for Windows version 3.3
Report Date: 2010/10/10 17:53:53










Open Disk
Test : RD-Read


Executing
Bad block found, start LBA : 60928
Block start at 412416 time 57ms
Block start at 417536 time 65ms
Block start at 566016 time 73ms
Block start at 624128 time 161ms
Block start at 790784 time 71ms
Block start at 917504 time 118ms
Block start at 918016 time 52ms
Block start at 922112 time 94ms
Block start at 926976 time 93ms
Block start at 930304 time 54ms
Block start at 1133312 time 153ms
Block start at 1137664 time 66ms
Block start at 1144576 time 121ms
Block start at 1157632 time 89ms
Block start at 1164544 time 97ms
Block start at 1166848 time 133ms
Block start at 1177600 time 65ms
Block start at 1205504 time 65ms
Block start at 1212416 time 81ms
Block start at 1524224 time 177ms
Block start at 1662976 time 81ms
Block start at 1733888 time 145ms
Block start at 1773568 time 57ms
Block start at 1787136 time 57ms
Block start at 2327552 time 65ms
Block start at 2359296 time 105ms
Block start at 2888960 time 89ms
Block start at 2902272 time 81ms
Block start at 2904576 time 105ms
Block start at 3420928 time 73ms
Block start at 3476736 time 57ms
Block start at 4551936 time 121ms
Block start at 4563968 time 106ms
Block start at 4606208 time 58ms
Block start at 4644096 time 121ms
Block start at 5089280 time 321ms
Block start at 5089536 time 358ms
Block start at 5089792 time 61ms
Block start at 5092608 time 57ms
Block start at 5100032 time 89ms
Block start at 5151488 time 113ms
Block start at 5151744 time 63ms
Block start at 5152000 time 57ms
Block start at 5176320 time 89ms
Block start at 5195264 time 241ms
Block start at 5216512 time 57ms
Block start at 5328896 time 50ms
Block start at 5767424 time 121ms
Block start at 5767680 time 50ms
Block start at 6237696 time 81ms
Block start at 6238720 time 84ms
Block start at 6284288 time 105ms
Block start at 6301952 time 57ms
Bad block found, start LBA : 6323200
Block start at 6323456 time 114ms
Block start at 6833664 time 121ms
Block start at 6848512 time 58ms
Block start at 6865920 time 89ms
Block start at 6898688 time 69ms
Block start at 6921472 time 65ms
Block start at 6926080 time 57ms
Block start at 7424256 time 81ms
Block start at 7425792 time 57ms
Block start at 7437824 time 57ms
Block start at 7481344 time 81ms
Block start at 7962880 time 73ms
Block start at 8280832 time 65ms
Block start at 8636160 time 58ms
Block start at 8651520 time 57ms
Block start at 9207040 time 57ms
Block start at 9672192 time 113ms
Block start at 9709824 time 73ms
Block start at 10039552 time 57ms
Block start at 10321664 time 50ms
Block start at 10824192 time 57ms
Block start at 11487232 time 73ms
Block start at 12056576 time 57ms
Block start at 12538112 time 65ms
Block start at 12555008 time 50ms
Block start at 13737472 time 57ms
Block start at 14335232 time 121ms
Block start at 15476992 time 145ms
Block start at 15481600 time 57ms
Block start at 16085760 time 161ms
Block start at 17758720 time 90ms
Block start at 18296320 time 65ms
Block start at 18328064 time 81ms
Block start at 18361600 time 57ms
Block start at 18943488 time 65ms
Block start at 19398400 time 65ms
Block start at 20007680 time 90ms
Block start at 20068864 time 65ms
Block start at 20091904 time 73ms
Block start at 20093184 time 88ms
Block start at 21150208 time 161ms
Block start at 21695232 time 105ms
Block start at 21742336 time 57ms
Block start at 21772288 time 65ms
Block start at 22837760 time 73ms
Block start at 22915584 time 65ms
Block start at 24630784 time 73ms
Block start at 26914304 time 81ms
Block start at 27419904 time 50ms
Block start at 27503104 time 73ms
Block start at 29953280 time 57ms
Block start at 30970624 time 73ms
Block start at 32559360 time 84ms
Block start at 34366976 time 66ms
Block start at 36640512 time 65ms
Block start at 38312448 time 58ms
Block start at 40132864 time 57ms
Block start at 40574208 time 76ms
Block start at 40674304 time 65ms
Block start at 40798976 time 439ms
Block start at 41161984 time 57ms
Block start at 42928896 time 177ms
Block start at 42942208 time 89ms
Block start at 43470080 time 82ms
Block start at 44040192 time 65ms
Bad block found, start LBA : 46903552
Block start at 46904064 time 126ms
Block start at 47115520 time 73ms
Block start at 47996672 time 185ms
Block start at 48041472 time 65ms
Block start at 48648192 time 81ms
Block start at 50484480 time 177ms
Block start at 50828800 time 52ms
Block start at 50856704 time 73ms
Block start at 50871552 time 65ms
Block start at 50878208 time 73ms
Block start at 51975424 time 65ms
Block start at 52509952 time 65ms
Block start at 52510208 time 54ms
Block start at 52573952 time 57ms
Block start at 53112576 time 89ms
Block start at 53139456 time 73ms
Block start at 53478912 time 57ms
Block start at 53661696 time 121ms
Block start at 55876608 time 121ms
Block start at 55909376 time 57ms
Block start at 55919360 time 105ms
Block start at 56773632 time 54ms
Block start at 61057792 time 65ms
Block start at 61712896 time 60ms
Block start at 62128640 time 68ms
Block start at 62187008 time 65ms
Block start at 67718656 time 106ms
Block start at 67729152 time 169ms
Block start at 67732480 time 81ms
Block start at 67815936 time 211ms
Block start at 68186112 time 56ms
Block start at 68329728 time 66ms
Block start at 68354304 time 60ms
Block start at 68855808 time 169ms
Block start at 70057472 time 52ms
Block start at 73925376 time 66ms
Block start at 74940416 time 53ms
Block start at 74990592 time 64ms
Block start at 78451968 time 89ms
Block start at 81747200 time 57ms
Block start at 85594880 time 129ms
Block start at 89130752 time 73ms
Block start at 89157632 time 153ms
Block start at 91719936 time 54ms
Block start at 96380672 time 50ms
Block start at 98140160 time 89ms
Block start at 103679488 time 50ms
Block start at 104836352 time 81ms
Block start at 105530880 time 66ms
Block start at 112500224 time 52ms
Block start at 114135040 time 65ms
Block start at 114142208 time 81ms
Block start at 137680384 time 61ms
Block start at 138087936 time 56ms
Block start at 145270016 time 91ms
Block start at 147366400 time 57ms
Block start at 167725056 time 58ms
Block start at 168465152 time 81ms
Block start at 173745664 time 169ms
Block start at 189205248 time 57ms
Block start at 208234496 time 57ms
Block start at 216244224 time 73ms
Block start at 216586752 time 106ms
Block start at 222842880 time 73ms
Block start at 228179712 time 54ms
Block start at 238070016 time 82ms
Block start at 240089088 time 81ms
Block start at 240121344 time 97ms
Block start at 246907136 time 54ms
Block start at 249231104 time 57ms
Block start at 252867840 time 65ms
Block start at 266175488 time 70ms
Block start at 266292992 time 54ms
Block start at 288733696 time 65ms
Block start at 310104320 time 54ms
Block start at 320214272 time 113ms
Block start at 327002368 time 277ms
Block start at 355354368 time 216ms
Block start at 355354624 time 207ms
Block start at 362604544 time 57ms
Block start at 365922816 time 97ms
Block start at 365946624 time 65ms
Block start at 366382336 time 97ms
Block start at 367342848 time 105ms
Block start at 367346176 time 66ms
Block start at 393369088 time 57ms
Block start at 399344384 time 89ms
Block start at 403980032 time 52ms
Block start at 407318528 time 73ms
Block start at 418746112 time 66ms
Block start at 420629760 time 81ms
Block start at 431465472 time 68ms
Block start at 443135488 time 81ms
Block start at 443476736 time 97ms
Block start at 445339392 time 73ms
Block start at 447548928 time 116ms
Block start at 465668096 time 60ms
Block start at 480663040 time 55ms
Block start at 487201792 time 73ms
Block start at 488836352 time 51ms
Block start at 490560256 time 76ms
Block start at 495256064 time 73ms
Block start at 495267840 time 51ms
Block start at 498617600 time 57ms
Block start at 498625536 time 91ms
Block start at 498975488 time 97ms
Block start at 498975744 time 57ms
Block start at 499024128 time 137ms
Block start at 499043840 time 57ms
Block start at 513577216 time 51ms
Block start at 516884480 time 61ms
Block start at 518042624 time 68ms
Block start at 527960576 time 50ms
Block start at 536522752 time 60ms
Block start at 536525312 time 218ms
Block start at 540088832 time 51ms
Block start at 543385344 time 81ms
Block start at 550810880 time 51ms
Block start at 558228480 time 53ms
Block start at 562516480 time 116ms
Block start at 573000960 time 54ms
Block start at 578408704 time 66ms
Block start at 585280256 time 90ms
Block start at 585634304 time 138ms
Block start at 586681600 time 50ms
Block start at 588852480 time 73ms
Block start at 591383552 time 52ms
Block start at 594276096 time 52ms
Block start at 598253568 time 100ms
Block start at 598976768 time 92ms
Block start at 606408192 time 93ms
Block start at 607177216 time 55ms
Block start at 611280128 time 90ms
Block start at 613822208 time 56ms
Block start at 614063872 time 133ms
Block start at 615107584 time 76ms
Block start at 615107840 time 129ms
Block start at 616847360 time 117ms
Block start at 617251328 time 50ms
Block start at 620313600 time 51ms
Block start at 620364288 time 54ms
Block start at 620439296 time 74ms
Block start at 620446720 time 50ms
Block start at 620703488 time 58ms
Block start at 621334784 time 66ms
Block start at 621368576 time 50ms
Block start at 621673472 time 82ms
Block start at 621987840 time 58ms
Block start at 622029056 time 58ms
Block start at 622033920 time 66ms
Block start at 622034432 time 98ms
Block start at 622653440 time 91ms
Block start at 622705152 time 66ms
Block start at 623098112 time 50ms
Block start at 623306240 time 51ms
Block start at 623345664 time 66ms
Block start at 624305152 time 61ms

北方星空

回复 5楼 wjcharles 的帖子

bads 就是坏道，保修期内换一个去吧。

另外《50ms的柱基本上这种读写速度会变慢，严重影响性能。

Lgwu

如有条件，备份出数据，格式化下看看。如果是逻辑坏道，普通格式化即可解决。
如果是物理的，那没办法，即使通过重新分区隐藏坏块也没什么用，这种情况下只有
去更换硬盘了。

峪飞鹰

5 重新分配扇区数量              100    100     36            2
191 震动传感出错率                100    100      0            7
195 硬件错误纠正次数               44     28      0     46798093
197 当前待映射扇区数量            100    100      0           27
198 离线无法纠正扇区数量          100    100      0           27

这几个项目已经表明，你的硬盘有问题了。

wjcharles

Lgwu 发表于 2010.10.11 01:09
如有条件，备份出数据，格式化下看看。如果是逻辑坏道，普通格式化即可解决。
如果是物理的，那没办法，即 ...

后来找了希捷官方的工具seatools，自己制作USB启动盘（官方只提供软盘和光盘镜像，但我光驱坏了），共修复了138个bad sector
seatools的说明文件里说，是用来判断是否需要保修的，如果检测后出现错误代码，才肯定需要保修，如果都修复了就没问题了

Ricty

北方星空 发表于 2010.10.10 23:44
回复 5楼 wjcharles 的帖子

bads 就是坏道，保修期内换一个去吧。

50ms以上就是影响性能的了？ 我的扫描报告和LZ的差不多，只是没有bads而已 那我还以为我的硬盘很健康呢