尘归尘，土归土！ 造谣者已被封号，谣言止于智者！

ubuntu

Unique ID use a scheme to send information from your computer to a company called Comodo. Even after uninstalling the software.

呵呵，这个 Unique ID 真猛，软件卸载了，还能给Comodo 发送信息。
很囧很强大

The EQs

只是一个防泄漏测试。。。。而不是综合的测试。。。。这种测试最适合带有hips功能的防火墙或者防病毒软件安全套装。。。能从防泄漏来评论一个防火墙的优劣？？？以前OP名次比较低，不照样有人用？lns也排到poor里面用的人同样不也是很多？？

[ 本帖最后由 EQ2 于 2007-8-10 05:43 编辑 ]

allenhippo

原帖由 EQ2 于 2007-8-10 05:37 发表
只是一个防泄漏测试。。。。而不是综合的测试。。。。这种测试最适合带有hips功能的防火墙或者防病毒软件安全套装。。。能从防泄漏来评论一个防火墙的优劣？？？以前OP名次比较低，不照样有人用？lns也排到poor ...

大哥我们没有讨论防火墙的优劣问题不要离题啊。

windows自带的还是得大鸭蛋呢，我不是还在用

yahoo121

这个墙还是不错的！
什么事情都得自己好好分析分析，不要别人说啥就是啥。

黄大蒜

呵呵 U老大还是脾气很大啊
很多东西还是用户用了知道 骂来骂去也没意思
我也相信COMODO不至于干间谍软件的事 以前都还说微软要控制全世界的电脑干坏事呢 现在还不都在用 呵呵
当然我也相信 没有一款软件是完美的

ubuntu

#61    Yesterday, 11:22 PM

Stem Firewall Expert Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: UK Posts: 2,888

Re: Comodo Firewall Privacy Intrusion !? Hello hiro, Quote: Originally Posted by hiro just to start, EVIDENCE: 1. existence of Unique ID This as always been known, and if users who install the firewall do not know this, then they obviously dont take note of the popups during installation:- But, as I have mentioned, if no e-mail is entered, and the option "Sign me up" is unchecked, I do not see any attempt by the firewall to connect out. Quote: Originally Posted by hiro 2. small part of code when firewall istalations create Unique ID Again, this just shows an ID is made. This does not mean that the Vendor is then going to "Track you". If this was the case, then we should also look at all other firewalls that have a "Unique ID", which they have, they are called a "License". We would also need to look at windows itself, the AV`s we install, and anything else that has a license(Unique ID) that connects to the internet. This only shows that an ID is generated, nothing else.

#62    Yesterday, 11:54 PM

LowWaterMark Administrator Join Date: Aug 2002 Location: CT, USA Posts: 11,564

Re: Comodo Firewall Privacy Intrusion !? Quote: Originally Posted by Stem But, as I have mentioned, if no e-mail is entered, and the option "Sign me up" is unchecked, I do not see any attempt by the firewall to connect out. Quote: Originally Posted by Stem Again, this just shows an ID is made. This does not mean that the Vendor is then going to "Track you". If this was the case, then we should also look at all other firewalls that have a "Unique ID", which they have, they are called a "License". We would also need to look at windows itself, the AV`s we install, and anything else that has a license(Unique ID) that connects to the internet. This only shows that an ID is generated, nothing else. Thank you Stem! If anyone is to be believed here, it is certainly you, not the Spreader of FUD - hiro. hiro - You are posting crap on Wilder Security Forums, and that is not welcome here. You really need to leave now! People - I am definitely not the biggest supporter of Comodo around, but, I do NOT believe this FUD at all, and I encourage you all to reject it, as well!! (I'm talking about any of their software products doing any illicit tracking. Whether they use Google Analytics or not on their website is not the issue. Tens of thousands of sites use that. But, no reputable vendor codes tracking calls into their firewall software - Comodo included!) I totally and completely doubt they are tracking everyone in the way Hiro has posted. I encourage everyone to read the threads over at the Comodo forums, and draw your own conclusions which I believe will tell you that they are not bad people at all. hiro - take your FUD to some other place on the Internet.

对于所谓的证据，Stem给予了有力的反驳。
对于整个事件，Wilders的管理员做了总结。
对于FUD 的散布者，下场就是封号，
hiro
Banned

尘归尘，土归土！谣言止于智者！

[ 本帖最后由 ubuntu 于 2007-8-10 18:20 编辑 ]

星之梦

Stem说的就足够了，这么简单的一个问题。。。

jpzy

呵呵，其实大家大可不必这样气愤～～～～～～

时间会证明一切的！

虽然我还没用过comodo，不过我很支持这款墙！

zerosu6652

对隐私无所谓

ktango

Stem已经说明一切。