Comparative tests
2009-08, 10 August-05 September
The test was made on 10 August-05 September 2009, using Windows XP Professional SP3 on a Pentium Dual Core 2Ghz, 2048MB DDRAM-2.
测试结果于8月10日至9月5日2009，使用Windows XP专业版SP3，Pentium Dual Core 2Ghz，2048MB DDR2 内存。
All programs tested had the latest versions, upgrades and updates and they were tested using their full scanning capabilities e.g. heuristics, full scan etc.
接受测试的所有程序先升级和更新至最新版本才进行测试，利用其扫描功能，例如启发式，全扫描等
The default settings of each program were not used, in order for each program to achieve its maximum detection rate. Because of this, there is a possibility for the tested programs to detect a few false positives.
为了使实现其最大的检出率，每个程序不使用默认设置。正因为如此，有一个程序将会有些误报的可能性。
All programs were updated on August 10th 2009, between 03.00AM and 07.00AM GMT.
所有程序都升级到2009年8月10日的上午07点至上午03时。
The 562086 virus samples were chosen using Kaspersky, F-Prot, Nod32, Dr.Web, BitDefender and McAfee antivirus programs’ reports. Each virus sample was unique by virus name, meaning that AT LEAST 1 antivirus program detected it as a new virus.
将使用 Kaspersky, F-Prot, Nod32, Dr.Web, BitDefender and McAfee 562086 病毒样本报告。每种病毒样本是唯一的病毒名称，这意味着至少有1个防病毒程序检测到一个新的病毒。
MS-DOS based virus samples were not used.
基于MS - DOS病毒样本都没有使用。
ALL virus samples were unpacked and the only samples that were kept were the ones that were packed using external-dos-packers (that means not winzip, winrar, winace etc).
所有病毒样本进行解包，以及那些只保留样本是那些使用外部包装- DOS的包装的（即不是winzip压缩软件，winace等）。
The virus samples had the correct file extension using a special program (Renexts) and were unique, according to checksum32 filesize.
该病毒样本的文件扩展名的正确使用一个特殊的程序（Renexts）是独一无二的，根据 checksum32 文件大小。
Most "fake" virus samples were removed, as well as "garbage" files.
最“假”病毒样本以及“垃圾”文件将被拆除。
The programs MKS_VIR , PER and IPArmor were not tested because there were no english demo versions available.
MKS_VIR , PER and IPArmor 没有进行试验，因为没有提供英文试用版本。
The program Extendia AVK was not tested because there was no demo version available.
Extendia AVK 没有进行试验，因为没有提供试用版本
Thorough mode was not used in VBA32 due to extremely slow scan process and heuristics were set to medium.
VBA32 由于非常缓慢的过程所以没使用彻底模式，启发式扫描设置为中等。
The Cleaner’s heuristics were set to medium due to many false positives.
The Cleaner’s 由于许多误报启发式被设置为中等。
The program F-Prot was tested using its command line scanner (options fpscan j:\avtest\trobo /adware /applications /output=fpscan_report.log /streams /maxdepth=4 /heurlevel=4) because its GUI kept crashing.
F-Prot 因为连续出现程序崩溃，进行测试时使用其命令行扫描程序（options fpscan j:\avtest\trobo /adware /applications /output=fpscan_report.log /streams /maxdepth=4 /heurlevel=4）。
The program ZondexGuard was not tested because it could not be updated.
ZondexGuard而没有进行测试，因为它无法更新。
The programs Microsoft Security Essentials and A-Squared Anti-Malware crashed while scanning the samples.
Microsoft Security Essentials and A-Squared Anti-Malware 扫描时出现程序崩溃。
The program Avast Professional uses the same engine as Avast free edition.
Avast专业版与Avast免费版使用相同引擎。
The program Steganos Antivirus uses the same engine as AVG free edition.
Steganos Antivirus使用与AVG免费版相同引擎。
The program Moon Secure uses the same engine as ClamWin.
Moon Secure使用与ClamWin相同引擎。
Rank
1. G DATA 2009 20.0.2.1 - 98,89%
2. F-Secure 2009 9.00.148 - 98,72%
3. Kaspersky 2010 9.0.0.463 - 98,67%
4. AntiVir 9.0.0.381 Premium - 98,64%
5. ZoneAlarm Antivirus 8.0.400.020 - 98,62%
6. AntiVir 9.0.0.407 Personal - 98,56%
7. Ashampoo 1.61 - 98,48%
8. MultiCore 2.001.00036 - 98,36%
9. Paretologic 6.1.1 - 98,11%
10. TrustPort 2.8.0.2255 - 98,03%
11. eScan 10.0.977.4091 - 97,82%
12. The Shield 2009 12.0.12 - 97,72%
13. BitDefender 2010 11.0.15.297 - 97,61%
14. Ikarus 1.0.97 - 97,15%
15. AVG 8.5.392 Free - 97%
16. BitDefender 2009 12.0.12.0 Free - 96,37%
17. Nod32 4.0.437.0 - 95,97%
18. Avast 4.8.1335 Free - 95,87%
19. Comodo 3.9.95478.509 - 95,57%
20. Trend Micro Antivirus 17.1.1250 - 95,36%
21. F-Prot 6.0.9.1 - 93,03%
22. McAfee Enterpise 8.7.0i - 92,35%
23. McAfee 13.11.102 - 92,32%
24. Norman Security Suite 7.10.0.1 - 90,76%
25. Blink Personal 4.3.2 - 90,17%
26. Vba32 3.12.10.9 - 89,91%
27. K7 Antivirus 7.7.0568 - 89,02%
28. Norton 16.5.0.134 - 87,37%
29. ArcaVir 2009 - 85,09%
30. Outpost 6.7.2957.446.0711 - 83,59%
31. Dr. Web 5.00.4.06300 - 82,89%
32. Rising AV 21.51 - 80,92%
33. Vipre 3.1.2775 - 79,69%
34. Kingsoft 2009.08.05.16 - 79,59%
35. V3 Internet Security 2009.08.10.02 - 79,24%
36. ViRobot Desktop 5.5 - 79,05%
37. Antiy Ghostbusters 6.1.6 - 77,14%
38. Panda 2009 9.00.00 - 70,8%
39. Twister 7.3.3.9983 - 67,14%
40. Virus Chaser 5.0a - 66,54%
41. Quick Heal 10.00 - 65,97%
42. PC Tools 6.0.0.19 - 59,77%
43. ClamWin 0.95.2 - 52,48%
44. Sophos Sweep 7.6.8 - 42,84%
45. Iolo 1.5.3 - 40,14%
46. Net Protector 2009 - 34,34%
47. The Cleaner 2010 Free 6.1.0.2007 - 34,11%
48. Digital Patrol 5.10.102 - 27,29%
49. Trojan Hunter 5.1.875 - 24%
50. Protector Plus 8.0.E02 - 21,61%
51. Solo 8.0 - 11,3%
52. Trojan Remover 6.8.1 - 11,16%
53. VirIT 6.4.71 - 9,01%
54. IOBit Security 360 beta 3.1 - 8,92%
55. PCClear 1.0.8.6 - 8,08%
[ 本帖最后由 sony_ung 于 2009-9-24 13:46 编辑 ] |
发表于 2009-9-24 13:43:58
楼主
发表于 2009-9-24 14:33:25
